Understanding compiler and linker flags

When building a program in C, C++, or other compiled languages, one typically invokes a compiler or compiler driver (like g++ or clang) with a list of command-line options. These options (often referred to as flags) tell the compiler how to compile (and sometimes link) your code.

I stumbled upon many of these compiling/linking commands through my software engineering career, and this blogpost kind of reflects my current understanding of these concepts, from both a theoretical and practical viewpoints.

In this post, we’ll cover:

• What flags are and how they’re used.
• The differences between compilation and linking.
• Detailed examples for CPU-only builds (GCC/Clang) and GPU-enabled builds (through CUDA’s nvccfor instance).
• Nuances like flag ordering, dual-phase flags, and platform-specific considerations.

1. What Are “Flags”?

Compiler flags control different aspects of the compilation process.

Typical flags include:

• I: Adds a directory to the compiler’s search path for header files.
• L: Adds a directory to the linker’s search path for libraries.
• l<name>: Links against a library named lib<name>.so (on Linux), lib<name>.dylib (on macOS), or lib<name>.a (static library).
• O3, O2, O0: Controls compilation optimization levels (O3 for advanced optimization, O0 for none).
• g: Generates debugging symbols for use with debuggers like gdb.
• fPIC: Generates Position-Independent Code (required for shared libraries, e.g. .so files).
• shared: Builds a shared library (e.g. .so on Linux).
• std=c++11 (or later standards like c++14, c++17): Specifies the C++ standard to use.
• fopenmp: Enables OpenMP support for multithreading.
• Xcompiler or Xlinker (in nvcc): Passes flags directly to the host compiler or linker.

These flags provide precise control over how your code is parsed, optimized, and linked.

2. How Do Flags Relate to Compilers?

2.1 Compilation vs. Linking

Compilation:

• The compiler translates your source code (.c, .cpp, etc.) into object files (.o, .obj).

Linking:

• A linker (often invoked implicitly by the compiler driver) combines object files and required libraries into a final executable (e.g. a.out) or library (e.g. .so, .dll).

Examples of Flag Usage:

• Compilation-only flags (e.g., I, std=c++11, fPIC, O3) instruct the compiler on parsing, header search paths, optimizations, etc.
• Linking-only flags (e.g., L, l) tell the linker where to find and which libraries to link against.
• Dual-phase flags: Some flags like fopenmp affect both the compilation and linking stages, adding necessary libraries during linking.

Note on Linker Flag Order:

The order of libraries in the linker command can sometimes matter, particularly with static libraries. If unresolved symbols appear, adjusting the order might resolve them.

2.2 Example of a Typical g++ Command

Compilation:

g++ -I/usr/local/include -O3 -std=c++11 -c myfile.cpp -o myfile.o

• I/usr/local/include: Look for header files in /usr/local/include.
• O3 and std=c++11: Enable advanced optimization and specify the C++ standard.
• c: Compile only (do not link). The output is myfile.o.

Linking:

g++ myfile.o -L/usr/local/lib -lm -o myapp

• L/usr/local/lib: Look for libraries in /usr/local/lib.
• lm: Link against the math library (libm.so on Linux).
• o myapp: Output an executable named myapp.

You can also combine these steps:

g++ -I/usr/local/include -O3 -std=c++11 myfile.cpp -L/usr/local/lib -lm -o myapp

Under the hood, the compiler first compiles, then links, all in one invocation.

3. What Are Linkers?

A linker is a program that resolves references between object files and external libraries. For example, if your code calls sqrt() from the math library, the linker locates where sqrt is defined (in libm.so on Linux, .so for shared objects) and links it into the final executable.

When you pass flags like -L/usr/local/lib -lm, you’re telling the linker to:

• L/usr/local/lib: Search /usr/local/lib for libraries.
• lm: Link against the math library (locating libm.so, libm.a, etc ….).

4. Why Use L and l?

• L<dir>: Adds <dir> to the linker’s search directories.
• l<name>: Tells the linker to look for a file named lib<name>.so, lib<name>.dylib, or lib<name>.a.

Example:

g++ main.o -L/home/me/mylibs -lfoo -o main

The linker checks /home/me/mylibs for libfoo.so (shared) or libfoo.a (static) and includes it in the final executable.

Static vs. Shared Libraries:

While the discussion above focuses on shared libraries (using flags like -shared and -fPIC), static libraries are linked differently. For static libraries, the linker includes the library code directly into the executable, and the flags used (-l<name>) point to .a files instead of .so or .dylib.

5. How Does a Compiler Work Internally?

Here’s a very simplified overview of the compilation process:

1. Preprocessing
   • Processes directives like #include and #define (for code in C/C++ for instance), expanding macros and including header files.
2. Parsing & Semantic Analysis
   • Converts the source code into an internal representation (often an Abstract Syntax Tree) and checks for errors (e.g. type mismatches).
3. Optimization
   • Applies optimizations based on flags such as O2 or O3.
4. Code Generation
   • Translates the optimized code into machine instructions (Assembly code).
5. Assembly & Object File Creation
   • The assembly is transformed into an object file (.o or .obj) containing machine code and unresolved symbols.
6. Linking
   • The linker merges multiple object files and libraries to produce the final executable or library.

6. Code Snippets of Typical Compiler/Linker Commands

6.1 C++ on Linux with a Shared Library

Compile:

g++ -fPIC -Iinclude -O3 -std=c++17 -c mylibrary.cpp -o mylibrary.o

• fPIC: Required for generating position-independent code for shared libraries.

Link:

g++ -shared -o libmylibrary.so mylibrary.o

• shared: Produces a .so shared object.

Using the Shared Library:

g++ main.cpp -Iinclude -L. -lmylibrary -o main

• Iinclude: Look for header files.
• L.: Look in the current directory for libraries.
• lmylibrary: Link against libmylibrary.so.

---

6.2 Using OpenMP

g++ -fopenmp -O3 main.cpp -o main

• fopenmp: Enables both compiler and linker support for OpenMP, automatically linking with the OpenMP runtime (e.g., libgomp).

---

6.3 Example with Clang on macOS

clang++ -std=c++14 -stdlib=libc++ -I/usr/local/include -L/usr/local/lib main.cpp -o myapp -lc++

• macOS often defaults to different standard libraries (libc++ vs. libstdc++), so specifying stdlib=libc++ and linking with lc++ is useful.
• Platform differences: Although this post focuses on Linux and macOS, note that Windows uses different conventions (such as .lib files).

7. CUDA Example

When compiling CUDA code, you typically use nvcc, NVIDIA’s compiler driver. Under the hood, nvcc calls the host compiler (like gcc or clang) for CPU code.

Basic CUDA Compilation:

nvcc -I/path/to/cuda/include -c mykernel.cu -o mykernel.o

More Complex Example:

nvcc -arch=sm_75 \\
     -I/usr/local/cuda/include \\
     -I/usr/local/include \\
     -L/usr/local/cuda/lib64 \\
     -lcudart \\
     -Xcompiler -fPIC \\
     -O3 -o mycudaapp main.cu

• arch=sm_75: Specifies the target GPU architecture (e.g., NVIDIA Turing).
• I/usr/local/cuda/include: Specifies the directory for CUDA headers (e.g cuda_runtime.h).
• L/usr/local/cuda/lib64 & lcudart: Directs the linker to the CUDA runtime library (libcudart.so).
• Xcompiler -fPIC: Passes fPIC to the host compiler.
• O3: Applies optimization.

8. Putting It All Together

• Headers (.h, .hpp)

  Found via -I paths.

• Libraries (libsomething.so, libsomething.a)

  Found via -L paths and included with -lsomething.

• Optimization and Standards

  Controlled via flags like -O2, -O3, and -std=c++17.

• Position-Independent Code (PIC)

  Required for shared libraries via -fPIC.

• Shared Library Output

  Created with -shared.

• OpenMP

  Enabled with -fopenmp, with consideration for dual-phase (compilation and linking) behavior.

• CUDA

  Managed by nvcc alongside host compiler flags, targeting specific GPU architectures with -arch=sm_xx.

9. Summary

Understanding compiler and linker flags is crucial for building functional and optimized software. Here’s what you need to remember:

• Compiler flags shape how the source code is processed, optimized, and debugged.
• Linker flags (L and l) determine how external libraries are located and included.
• A linker resolves external symbols by combining object files and libraries.
• CUDA builds require managing both device and host code, with nvcc orchestrating the process.
• Platform Nuances & Ordering: Pay attention to the order of linker flags and be aware of platform-specific differences (Linux, macOS, Windows).

By carefully controlling these flags, you can ensure your project is both robust and efficient.